The police didn't read me my rights
New Title
THE POLICE DIDN’T READ ME MY MIRANDA RIGHTS
A common complaint we hear from clients who have come to us for help after being arrested is the police did not read them their Miranda rights. Many clients seem to think that because the police did not read them their rights the arrest in illegal or the case should be dropped. This is usually a misconception. Briefly, this is your right to remain silent and not be compelled to be a witness against yourself under the Fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution. They are called Miranda rights based on a United States Supreme Court case from the 1960s, Miranda v. Arizona.
Because we hear this complaint so often is it important to remember what the failure of the police to read your Miranda rights actually means. In short, if you are in custody AND the police are asking you questions, the answers to those questions cannot be used against you if you have not been advised of your right to remain silent. The question of what is “in custody” can be tricky at times and often depends of the particular facts of the situation, but normally involves a situation where your freedom of movement has been restrained and you are not “free to go”. Are you in handcuffs? You’re in custody.
The failure to advise you of your rights has nothing to do with the validity of the arrest or the proof of the crime charged/investigated. Put another way, the fact the police did not read you your rights before arresting you has no effect on whether they can prove the charges. That is, if the police arrested you without asking you any questions, the fact they did not read your rights has no legal consequences. Secondly, spontaneous statements by an accused which are not in response to questioning are not protected by the failure to read you your rights. If you blurt something out that is not in response to questioning it can be used against you.
There are situations where the police can question you and your answers be used against you because you are not in custody. This typically occurs in a traffic stop. In that situation you must provide your driver license, registration and proof of insurance. It also important to note the police are likely to ask questions like where have you been, where are you going or more incriminating “have you been drinking” while they are still getting documents at your window. You have no obligation to answer these questions. If you do, however, it is likely those answers are going to be used against you.
The law is a little different if you have been in a car crash. Under the accident report privilege in Florida you DO have an obligation to talk to the police, but because of the statutory privilege the statements you make cannot be used in a later criminal proceeding. That privile ge requires you to answer questions if you were the driver in a car crash. However, if the police tell you that they are now conducting a criminal investigation, any statement you make after that point are no longer protected by the accident report privilege.
There are a number of things to be aware of when talking to the police. If they are talking to you about a crime there is a high likelihood you are or may be a suspect. The warning here is simple. Don’t talk; you are not going to talk the police out of arresting you. Invoking your right to remain silent cannot later be used against you. No jury is going to hear you “took the Fifth”.
Police are allowed to lie to you and when conducting interviews they frequently do to catch you in a lie. Another thing to remember is that the police have limited authority to make deals; for example, if an officer tells you that if you tell him where the stolen goods, or money or drugs or guns are etc... the State Attorney will go easy on you. Don’t be fooled by this. Only the prosecutor has the legal authority to make such promises that are binding in court. So beware.
If you are in jail: don’t talk, not to another inmate, not on the phone. There is no requirement you be read your rights after you are in jail. Jail phone calls are monitored and other inmates trying to get favorable treatment on their cases will inform on you.
It is also a common misconception that all interviews are recorded. They aren’t. Equally important to understand is police techniques to gain trust These can involve small talk, good cop/bad cop, diverting attention away from the crime itself or making one think the “Miranda” rights are just a formality with expressions, for example like “I have to read this to you”. Your constitutional rights are not a formality. If you have been told you have the right to remain silent and a lawyer will be afforded before any questioning; STOP TALKING. It is not a formality.
Miranda warnings only apply to government agenices like the police, the FBI or some other agency. They do not apply to private persons or corporations. A store security guards\ who might be interviewing you about a retail theft has no obligation to warn you about your right to remain silent
In short your right to remain silent is a warning. Pay attention warning and remain silent.






